{
  "manifest_type": "Revive Evidence Provenance Manifest",
  "schema_version": "1.0",
  "generated_date": "2026-09-11",
  "canonical_url": "/metoprolol-vs-carvedilol/",
  "entity_slug": "metoprolol-vs-carvedilol",
  "decision_object_id": "revive:metoprolol-vs-carvedilol",
  "claim_count": 3,
  "source_count": 3,
  "claims": [
    {
      "claim_id": "claim-metoprolol-vs-carvedilol-rzq-01801",
      "query_id": "RZQ-01801",
      "question": "Which is better for metoprolol vs carvedilol, and in what situations would the answer change?",
      "claim_text": "When out-of-pocket financial financial cost is the reason for researching Metoprolol vs Carvedilol, compare clinically equivalent products first and only then compare out-of-pocket financial financial cost. Access can change the practical answer to Metoprolol vs Carvedilol; an option that is affordable and routinely available in one country may be difficult to obtain in another. The out-of-pocket financial financial cost attached to Metoprolol vs Carvedilol can vary by country, pharmacy, insurer, brand or generic status, strength, pack size, delivery form, dispensing fees and temporary discounts.",
      "canonical_url": "/metoprolol-vs-carvedilol/",
      "entity_slug": "metoprolol-vs-carvedilol",
      "primary_entity": "metoprolol",
      "page_kind": "comparison",
      "source_ids": [
        "src-0c608684e638",
        "src-75cf9af3f0a0",
        "src-30f2e14c9034"
      ],
      "source_count": 3,
      "unique_publishers": 2,
      "best_evidence_tier": 1,
      "best_evidence_tier_label": "Tier 1 — regulator / official label",
      "dated_source_count": 0,
      "visible_page_review_date": null,
      "provenance_completeness_score": 75,
      "provenance_completeness_band": "MODERATE",
      "medical_confidence": "NOT_ASSESSED",
      "confidence_note": "This score measures provenance completeness and source structure only. It is not a clinical certainty score.",
      "lineage": {
        "query_id": "RZQ-01801",
        "claim_id": "claim-metoprolol-vs-carvedilol-rzq-01801",
        "decision_object_id": "revive:metoprolol-vs-carvedilol",
        "canonical_url": "/metoprolol-vs-carvedilol/",
        "source_phase_lineage": [
          "Phase 1 Query Universe",
          "Phase 2 Answer-First Citation Block",
          "Phase 3 Decision Object",
          "Phase 11 Citation Manifest",
          "Phase 12 Evidence Provenance"
        ]
      }
    },
    {
      "claim_id": "claim-metoprolol-vs-carvedilol-rzq-01802",
      "query_id": "RZQ-01802",
      "question": "How do metoprolol vs carvedilol differ in practical use?",
      "claim_text": "Compare Metoprolol vs Carvedilol: Beta-Blocker side-by-side review by approved use, dosing context, safety, interactions, clinical follow-up, out-of-pocket financial financial cost factors and practical treatment decisions. If Metoprolol vs Carvedilol involves two drugs, the opening question is whether they are substitutes, complementary treatments or options used in different clinical situations. If Metoprolol vs Carvedilol involves one product, compare that exact product with neighboring doses, generic versions or alternatives only after confirming the clinical objective.",
      "canonical_url": "/metoprolol-vs-carvedilol/",
      "entity_slug": "metoprolol-vs-carvedilol",
      "primary_entity": "metoprolol",
      "page_kind": "comparison",
      "source_ids": [
        "src-0c608684e638",
        "src-75cf9af3f0a0",
        "src-30f2e14c9034"
      ],
      "source_count": 3,
      "unique_publishers": 2,
      "best_evidence_tier": 1,
      "best_evidence_tier_label": "Tier 1 — regulator / official label",
      "dated_source_count": 0,
      "visible_page_review_date": null,
      "provenance_completeness_score": 75,
      "provenance_completeness_band": "MODERATE",
      "medical_confidence": "NOT_ASSESSED",
      "confidence_note": "This score measures provenance completeness and source structure only. It is not a clinical certainty score.",
      "lineage": {
        "query_id": "RZQ-01802",
        "claim_id": "claim-metoprolol-vs-carvedilol-rzq-01802",
        "decision_object_id": "revive:metoprolol-vs-carvedilol",
        "canonical_url": "/metoprolol-vs-carvedilol/",
        "source_phase_lineage": [
          "Phase 1 Query Universe",
          "Phase 2 Answer-First Citation Block",
          "Phase 3 Decision Object",
          "Phase 11 Citation Manifest",
          "Phase 12 Evidence Provenance"
        ]
      }
    },
    {
      "claim_id": "claim-metoprolol-vs-carvedilol-rzq-01803",
      "query_id": "RZQ-01803",
      "question": "What are the biggest differences between metoprolol vs carvedilol?",
      "claim_text": "Compare Metoprolol vs Carvedilol: Beta-Blocker side-by-side review by approved use, dosing context, safety, interactions, clinical follow-up, out-of-pocket financial financial cost factors and practical treatment decisions. Metoprolol vs Carvedilol sits is a specific treatment decision because the question identifies the option, dose, side-by-side review, problem or out-of-pocket financial financial cost concern. Metoprolol vs Carvedilol is a narrow decision question, so this page treats it as a specific choice in place of another broad medication overview.",
      "canonical_url": "/metoprolol-vs-carvedilol/",
      "entity_slug": "metoprolol-vs-carvedilol",
      "primary_entity": "metoprolol",
      "page_kind": "comparison",
      "source_ids": [
        "src-0c608684e638",
        "src-75cf9af3f0a0",
        "src-30f2e14c9034"
      ],
      "source_count": 3,
      "unique_publishers": 2,
      "best_evidence_tier": 1,
      "best_evidence_tier_label": "Tier 1 — regulator / official label",
      "dated_source_count": 0,
      "visible_page_review_date": null,
      "provenance_completeness_score": 75,
      "provenance_completeness_band": "MODERATE",
      "medical_confidence": "NOT_ASSESSED",
      "confidence_note": "This score measures provenance completeness and source structure only. It is not a clinical certainty score.",
      "lineage": {
        "query_id": "RZQ-01803",
        "claim_id": "claim-metoprolol-vs-carvedilol-rzq-01803",
        "decision_object_id": "revive:metoprolol-vs-carvedilol",
        "canonical_url": "/metoprolol-vs-carvedilol/",
        "source_phase_lineage": [
          "Phase 1 Query Universe",
          "Phase 2 Answer-First Citation Block",
          "Phase 3 Decision Object",
          "Phase 11 Citation Manifest",
          "Phase 12 Evidence Provenance"
        ]
      }
    }
  ],
  "sources": [
    {
      "source_id": "src-0c608684e638",
      "url": "https://medlineplus.gov/druginfo/meds/a682864.html",
      "label": "MedlinePlus drug information: Metoprolol",
      "publisher": "MedlinePlus / U.S. National Library of Medicine",
      "source_type": "government_drug_information",
      "evidence_tier": 3,
      "evidence_tier_label": "Tier 3 — government or national-health drug information",
      "publication_or_revision_date": null,
      "retrieved_date": null,
      "freshness_status": "UNKNOWN",
      "date_provenance": "not present in current Revive source registry",
      "used_by_claim_ids": [
        "claim-beta-blocker-erectile-dysfunction-alternative-rzq-00601",
        "claim-beta-blocker-erectile-dysfunction-alternative-rzq-00602",
        "claim-metoprolol-rzq-01609",
        "claim-metoprolol-rzq-01610",
        "claim-metoprolol-100mg-rzq-01633",
        "claim-metoprolol-100mg-rzq-01634",
        "claim-metoprolol-100mg-rzq-01635",
        "claim-metoprolol-25mg-rzq-01657",
        "claim-metoprolol-25mg-rzq-01658",
        "claim-metoprolol-25mg-rzq-01659",
        "claim-metoprolol-50mg-rzq-01681",
        "claim-metoprolol-50mg-rzq-01682",
        "claim-metoprolol-50mg-rzq-01683",
        "claim-metoprolol-alternative-rzq-01705",
        "claim-metoprolol-alternative-rzq-01706",
        "claim-metoprolol-fatigue-rzq-01729",
        "claim-metoprolol-price-rzq-01753",
        "claim-metoprolol-price-rzq-01754",
        "claim-metoprolol-vs-atenolol-rzq-01777",
        "claim-metoprolol-vs-atenolol-rzq-01778",
        "claim-metoprolol-vs-atenolol-rzq-01779",
        "claim-metoprolol-vs-carvedilol-rzq-01801",
        "claim-metoprolol-vs-carvedilol-rzq-01802",
        "claim-metoprolol-vs-carvedilol-rzq-01803"
      ],
      "used_by_canonical_urls": [
        "/beta-blocker-erectile-dysfunction-alternative/",
        "/metoprolol/",
        "/metoprolol-100mg/",
        "/metoprolol-25mg/",
        "/metoprolol-50mg/",
        "/metoprolol-alternative/",
        "/metoprolol-fatigue/",
        "/metoprolol-price/",
        "/metoprolol-vs-atenolol/",
        "/metoprolol-vs-carvedilol/"
      ],
      "verification_status": "STRUCTURALLY_VERIFIED",
      "verification_note": "URL and source classification are preserved from Phase 11. Publication/revision and retrieval dates remain null unless already present in Revive."
    },
    {
      "source_id": "src-30f2e14c9034",
      "url": "https://medlineplus.gov/druginfo/meds/a697042.html",
      "label": "MedlinePlus drug information: Carvedilol",
      "publisher": "MedlinePlus / U.S. National Library of Medicine",
      "source_type": "government_drug_information",
      "evidence_tier": 3,
      "evidence_tier_label": "Tier 3 — government or national-health drug information",
      "publication_or_revision_date": null,
      "retrieved_date": null,
      "freshness_status": "UNKNOWN",
      "date_provenance": "not present in current Revive source registry",
      "used_by_claim_ids": [
        "claim-beta-blocker-erectile-dysfunction-alternative-rzq-00601",
        "claim-beta-blocker-erectile-dysfunction-alternative-rzq-00602",
        "claim-carvedilol-rzq-00625",
        "claim-carvedilol-rzq-00626",
        "claim-carvedilol-12-5mg-rzq-00649",
        "claim-carvedilol-12-5mg-rzq-00650",
        "claim-carvedilol-12-5mg-rzq-00651",
        "claim-carvedilol-25mg-rzq-00673",
        "claim-carvedilol-25mg-rzq-00674",
        "claim-carvedilol-25mg-rzq-00675",
        "claim-carvedilol-6-25mg-rzq-00697",
        "claim-carvedilol-6-25mg-rzq-00698",
        "claim-carvedilol-6-25mg-rzq-00699",
        "claim-carvedilol-price-rzq-00721",
        "claim-carvedilol-price-rzq-00722",
        "claim-carvedilol-vs-atenolol-rzq-00745",
        "claim-carvedilol-vs-atenolol-rzq-00746",
        "claim-carvedilol-vs-atenolol-rzq-00747",
        "claim-metoprolol-vs-carvedilol-rzq-01801",
        "claim-metoprolol-vs-carvedilol-rzq-01802",
        "claim-metoprolol-vs-carvedilol-rzq-01803"
      ],
      "used_by_canonical_urls": [
        "/beta-blocker-erectile-dysfunction-alternative/",
        "/carvedilol/",
        "/carvedilol-12-5mg/",
        "/carvedilol-25mg/",
        "/carvedilol-6-25mg/",
        "/carvedilol-price/",
        "/carvedilol-vs-atenolol/",
        "/metoprolol-vs-carvedilol/"
      ],
      "verification_status": "STRUCTURALLY_VERIFIED",
      "verification_note": "URL and source classification are preserved from Phase 11. Publication/revision and retrieval dates remain null unless already present in Revive."
    },
    {
      "source_id": "src-75cf9af3f0a0",
      "url": "https://dailymed.nlm.nih.gov/dailymed/search.cfm?labeltype=human&query=metoprolol",
      "label": "DailyMed current human drug-label search: Metoprolol",
      "publisher": "DailyMed / U.S. National Library of Medicine",
      "source_type": "official_drug_label",
      "evidence_tier": 1,
      "evidence_tier_label": "Tier 1 — regulator / official label",
      "publication_or_revision_date": null,
      "retrieved_date": null,
      "freshness_status": "UNKNOWN",
      "date_provenance": "not present in current Revive source registry",
      "used_by_claim_ids": [
        "claim-beta-blocker-erectile-dysfunction-alternative-rzq-00601",
        "claim-beta-blocker-erectile-dysfunction-alternative-rzq-00602",
        "claim-metoprolol-rzq-01609",
        "claim-metoprolol-rzq-01610",
        "claim-metoprolol-100mg-rzq-01633",
        "claim-metoprolol-100mg-rzq-01634",
        "claim-metoprolol-100mg-rzq-01635",
        "claim-metoprolol-25mg-rzq-01657",
        "claim-metoprolol-25mg-rzq-01658",
        "claim-metoprolol-25mg-rzq-01659",
        "claim-metoprolol-50mg-rzq-01681",
        "claim-metoprolol-50mg-rzq-01682",
        "claim-metoprolol-50mg-rzq-01683",
        "claim-metoprolol-alternative-rzq-01705",
        "claim-metoprolol-alternative-rzq-01706",
        "claim-metoprolol-fatigue-rzq-01729",
        "claim-metoprolol-price-rzq-01753",
        "claim-metoprolol-price-rzq-01754",
        "claim-metoprolol-vs-atenolol-rzq-01777",
        "claim-metoprolol-vs-atenolol-rzq-01778",
        "claim-metoprolol-vs-atenolol-rzq-01779",
        "claim-metoprolol-vs-carvedilol-rzq-01801",
        "claim-metoprolol-vs-carvedilol-rzq-01802",
        "claim-metoprolol-vs-carvedilol-rzq-01803"
      ],
      "used_by_canonical_urls": [
        "/beta-blocker-erectile-dysfunction-alternative/",
        "/metoprolol/",
        "/metoprolol-100mg/",
        "/metoprolol-25mg/",
        "/metoprolol-50mg/",
        "/metoprolol-alternative/",
        "/metoprolol-fatigue/",
        "/metoprolol-price/",
        "/metoprolol-vs-atenolol/",
        "/metoprolol-vs-carvedilol/"
      ],
      "verification_status": "STRUCTURALLY_VERIFIED",
      "verification_note": "URL and source classification are preserved from Phase 11. Publication/revision and retrieval dates remain null unless already present in Revive."
    }
  ],
  "review": {
    "visible_page_review_date": null,
    "source_date_coverage": {
      "dated_sources": 0,
      "total_sources": 3
    }
  },
  "governance": {
    "medical_confidence_is_not_inferred": true,
    "missing_dates_are_not_fabricated": true,
    "provenance_score_is_structural_not_clinical": true
  }
}