{ "manifest_type": "Revive Evidence Provenance Manifest", "schema_version": "1.0", "generated_date": "2026-09-11", "canonical_url": "/carvedilol-vs-atenolol/", "entity_slug": "carvedilol-vs-atenolol", "decision_object_id": "revive:carvedilol-vs-atenolol", "claim_count": 3, "source_count": 3, "claims": [ { "claim_id": "claim-carvedilol-vs-atenolol-rzq-00745", "query_id": "RZQ-00745", "question": "Which is better for carvedilol vs atenolol, and in what situations would the answer change?", "claim_text": "Carvedilol vs Atenolol becomes a better decision when the reader separates treatment requirements from ease of use, price and marketing claims. A credible answer to Carvedilol vs Atenolol explains what is known, what remains unknown and what information should be verified before action. For Carvedilol vs Atenolol, specificity is more informative than certainty theater; the page should show what changes the decision instead of pretending one answer fits everyone.", "canonical_url": "/carvedilol-vs-atenolol/", "entity_slug": "carvedilol-vs-atenolol", "primary_entity": "carvedilol", "page_kind": "comparison", "source_ids": [ "src-30f2e14c9034", "src-dd695e2ab04e", "src-f88299ed23cc" ], "source_count": 3, "unique_publishers": 2, "best_evidence_tier": 1, "best_evidence_tier_label": "Tier 1 — regulator / official label", "dated_source_count": 0, "visible_page_review_date": null, "provenance_completeness_score": 75, "provenance_completeness_band": "MODERATE", "medical_confidence": "NOT_ASSESSED", "confidence_note": "This score measures provenance completeness and source structure only. It is not a clinical certainty score.", "lineage": { "query_id": "RZQ-00745", "claim_id": "claim-carvedilol-vs-atenolol-rzq-00745", "decision_object_id": "revive:carvedilol-vs-atenolol", "canonical_url": "/carvedilol-vs-atenolol/", "source_phase_lineage": [ "Phase 1 Query Universe", "Phase 2 Answer-First Citation Block", "Phase 3 Decision Object", "Phase 11 Citation Manifest", "Phase 12 Evidence Provenance" ] } }, { "claim_id": "claim-carvedilol-vs-atenolol-rzq-00746", "query_id": "RZQ-00746", "question": "How do carvedilol vs atenolol differ in practical use?", "claim_text": "Compare Carvedilol vs Atenolol: Beta-Blocker decision comparison by approved use, dosing context, clinical safety, interactions, monitoring, price factors and practical treatment decisions. For Carvedilol vs Atenolol, a lower package price is not automatically a lower treatment price if the number of doses, strength, schedule or dosage form differs. A global page about Carvedilol vs Atenolol should explain price drivers instead of merely invent one worldwide price that will be wrong for many readers.", "canonical_url": "/carvedilol-vs-atenolol/", "entity_slug": "carvedilol-vs-atenolol", "primary_entity": "carvedilol", "page_kind": "comparison", "source_ids": [ "src-30f2e14c9034", "src-dd695e2ab04e", "src-f88299ed23cc" ], "source_count": 3, "unique_publishers": 2, "best_evidence_tier": 1, "best_evidence_tier_label": "Tier 1 — regulator / official label", "dated_source_count": 0, "visible_page_review_date": null, "provenance_completeness_score": 75, "provenance_completeness_band": "MODERATE", "medical_confidence": "NOT_ASSESSED", "confidence_note": "This score measures provenance completeness and source structure only. It is not a clinical certainty score.", "lineage": { "query_id": "RZQ-00746", "claim_id": "claim-carvedilol-vs-atenolol-rzq-00746", "decision_object_id": "revive:carvedilol-vs-atenolol", "canonical_url": "/carvedilol-vs-atenolol/", "source_phase_lineage": [ "Phase 1 Query Universe", "Phase 2 Answer-First Citation Block", "Phase 3 Decision Object", "Phase 11 Citation Manifest", "Phase 12 Evidence Provenance" ] } }, { "claim_id": "claim-carvedilol-vs-atenolol-rzq-00747", "query_id": "RZQ-00747", "question": "What are the biggest differences between carvedilol vs atenolol?", "claim_text": "Compare Carvedilol vs Atenolol: Beta-Blocker decision comparison by approved use, dosing context, clinical safety, interactions, monitoring, price factors and practical treatment decisions. A search for Carvedilol vs Atenolol cannot tell whether the main problem is efficacy, ability to tolerate treatment, ease of use, interaction risk, price or simple curiosity. The name or dose alone does not contain enough clinical information to support a individual prescribing choice.", "canonical_url": "/carvedilol-vs-atenolol/", "entity_slug": "carvedilol-vs-atenolol", "primary_entity": "carvedilol", "page_kind": "comparison", "source_ids": [ "src-30f2e14c9034", "src-dd695e2ab04e", "src-f88299ed23cc" ], "source_count": 3, "unique_publishers": 2, "best_evidence_tier": 1, "best_evidence_tier_label": "Tier 1 — regulator / official label", "dated_source_count": 0, "visible_page_review_date": null, "provenance_completeness_score": 75, "provenance_completeness_band": "MODERATE", "medical_confidence": "NOT_ASSESSED", "confidence_note": "This score measures provenance completeness and source structure only. It is not a clinical certainty score.", "lineage": { "query_id": "RZQ-00747", "claim_id": "claim-carvedilol-vs-atenolol-rzq-00747", "decision_object_id": "revive:carvedilol-vs-atenolol", "canonical_url": "/carvedilol-vs-atenolol/", "source_phase_lineage": [ "Phase 1 Query Universe", "Phase 2 Answer-First Citation Block", "Phase 3 Decision Object", "Phase 11 Citation Manifest", "Phase 12 Evidence Provenance" ] } } ], "sources": [ { "source_id": "src-30f2e14c9034", "url": "https://medlineplus.gov/druginfo/meds/a697042.html", "label": "MedlinePlus drug information: Carvedilol", "publisher": "MedlinePlus / U.S. National Library of Medicine", "source_type": "government_drug_information", "evidence_tier": 3, "evidence_tier_label": "Tier 3 — government or national-health drug information", "publication_or_revision_date": null, "retrieved_date": null, "freshness_status": "UNKNOWN", "date_provenance": "not present in current Revive source registry", "used_by_claim_ids": [ "claim-beta-blocker-erectile-dysfunction-alternative-rzq-00601", "claim-beta-blocker-erectile-dysfunction-alternative-rzq-00602", "claim-carvedilol-rzq-00625", "claim-carvedilol-rzq-00626", "claim-carvedilol-12-5mg-rzq-00649", "claim-carvedilol-12-5mg-rzq-00650", "claim-carvedilol-12-5mg-rzq-00651", "claim-carvedilol-25mg-rzq-00673", "claim-carvedilol-25mg-rzq-00674", "claim-carvedilol-25mg-rzq-00675", "claim-carvedilol-6-25mg-rzq-00697", "claim-carvedilol-6-25mg-rzq-00698", "claim-carvedilol-6-25mg-rzq-00699", "claim-carvedilol-price-rzq-00721", "claim-carvedilol-price-rzq-00722", "claim-carvedilol-vs-atenolol-rzq-00745", "claim-carvedilol-vs-atenolol-rzq-00746", "claim-carvedilol-vs-atenolol-rzq-00747", "claim-metoprolol-vs-carvedilol-rzq-01801", "claim-metoprolol-vs-carvedilol-rzq-01802", "claim-metoprolol-vs-carvedilol-rzq-01803" ], "used_by_canonical_urls": [ "/beta-blocker-erectile-dysfunction-alternative/", "/carvedilol/", "/carvedilol-12-5mg/", "/carvedilol-25mg/", "/carvedilol-6-25mg/", "/carvedilol-price/", "/carvedilol-vs-atenolol/", "/metoprolol-vs-carvedilol/" ], "verification_status": "STRUCTURALLY_VERIFIED", "verification_note": "URL and source classification are preserved from Phase 11. Publication/revision and retrieval dates remain null unless already present in Revive." }, { "source_id": "src-dd695e2ab04e", "url": "https://dailymed.nlm.nih.gov/dailymed/search.cfm?labeltype=human&query=carvedilol", "label": "DailyMed current human drug-label search: Carvedilol", "publisher": "DailyMed / U.S. National Library of Medicine", "source_type": "official_drug_label", "evidence_tier": 1, "evidence_tier_label": "Tier 1 — regulator / official label", "publication_or_revision_date": null, "retrieved_date": null, "freshness_status": "UNKNOWN", "date_provenance": "not present in current Revive source registry", "used_by_claim_ids": [ "claim-carvedilol-rzq-00625", "claim-carvedilol-rzq-00626", "claim-carvedilol-12-5mg-rzq-00649", "claim-carvedilol-12-5mg-rzq-00650", "claim-carvedilol-12-5mg-rzq-00651", "claim-carvedilol-25mg-rzq-00673", "claim-carvedilol-25mg-rzq-00674", "claim-carvedilol-25mg-rzq-00675", "claim-carvedilol-6-25mg-rzq-00697", "claim-carvedilol-6-25mg-rzq-00698", "claim-carvedilol-6-25mg-rzq-00699", "claim-carvedilol-price-rzq-00721", "claim-carvedilol-price-rzq-00722", "claim-carvedilol-vs-atenolol-rzq-00745", "claim-carvedilol-vs-atenolol-rzq-00746", "claim-carvedilol-vs-atenolol-rzq-00747" ], "used_by_canonical_urls": [ "/carvedilol/", "/carvedilol-12-5mg/", "/carvedilol-25mg/", "/carvedilol-6-25mg/", "/carvedilol-price/", "/carvedilol-vs-atenolol/" ], "verification_status": "STRUCTURALLY_VERIFIED", "verification_note": "URL and source classification are preserved from Phase 11. Publication/revision and retrieval dates remain null unless already present in Revive." }, { "source_id": "src-f88299ed23cc", "url": "https://medlineplus.gov/druginfo/meds/a684031.html", "label": "MedlinePlus drug information: Atenolol", "publisher": "MedlinePlus / U.S. National Library of Medicine", "source_type": "government_drug_information", "evidence_tier": 3, "evidence_tier_label": "Tier 3 — government or national-health drug information", "publication_or_revision_date": null, "retrieved_date": null, "freshness_status": "UNKNOWN", "date_provenance": "not present in current Revive source registry", "used_by_claim_ids": [ "claim-atenolol-rzq-00289", "claim-atenolol-rzq-00290", "claim-atenolol-100mg-rzq-00313", "claim-atenolol-100mg-rzq-00314", "claim-atenolol-100mg-rzq-00315", "claim-atenolol-50mg-rzq-00337", "claim-atenolol-50mg-rzq-00338", "claim-atenolol-50mg-rzq-00339", "claim-atenolol-price-rzq-00361", "claim-atenolol-price-rzq-00362", "claim-carvedilol-vs-atenolol-rzq-00745", "claim-carvedilol-vs-atenolol-rzq-00746", "claim-carvedilol-vs-atenolol-rzq-00747", "claim-metoprolol-vs-atenolol-rzq-01777", "claim-metoprolol-vs-atenolol-rzq-01778", "claim-metoprolol-vs-atenolol-rzq-01779" ], "used_by_canonical_urls": [ "/atenolol/", "/atenolol-100mg/", "/atenolol-50mg/", "/atenolol-price/", "/carvedilol-vs-atenolol/", "/metoprolol-vs-atenolol/" ], "verification_status": "STRUCTURALLY_VERIFIED", "verification_note": "URL and source classification are preserved from Phase 11. Publication/revision and retrieval dates remain null unless already present in Revive." } ], "review": { "visible_page_review_date": null, "source_date_coverage": { "dated_sources": 0, "total_sources": 3 } }, "governance": { "medical_confidence_is_not_inferred": true, "missing_dates_are_not_fabricated": true, "provenance_score_is_structural_not_clinical": true } }